| 
   | Results |  |  |  |  |  |  |  
   | Status: soft result (plausible score) |  
Event table notes
 | 
| Event data |  | 
   | Place: New York |  
   | Start date: Sep. 1867 |  
   | End date:   Sep. 1867 |  |  |  
   | Notes: |  
   | Turf, Field and Farm (28 Sep. 1867) says that they played 'a large number of games' and McConnell got only two draws. I represent this with a soft score of +6-0=2. |  |  |  |  
   | References |  |  |  |