Kolisch, I. – Barnes, T.W. 1860




Results
 
Name   Edo    Dev.   Score  /  Games 
Kolisch, Ignatz    2650 (33) 2.5/
Barnes, Thomas    2444 (52) 0.5/
 
Status: formal

Event table notes

Event data
Place: London
Start date: July 1860
End date: July 1860
 
Notes:
Spinrad lists results for Kolisch-Barnes under the year 1859, and an obituary for Kolisch in the Chess Monthly of May 1889 (see Sarah's 'Death of Baron Kolisch' web page) implies this, saying that Kolisch went to England in 1859, and gives the result as 12-1 for Kolisch. Feenstra Kuiper, Golombek and Di Felice give +10-1=0 in 1860, and Golombek says Kolisch only came to England in 1860. Hooper and Whyld also give +10-1 but without a date. Sergeant gives +8-1=1 for Kolisch in 1861 in A Century of British Chess (p.107). The Chess Player's Chronicle of June 1861 (p.185) has +8-1=1 and says the games were played in May (1861). Staunton, in the Illustrated London News of 18 Aug. 1860 (p.164) says the match was in progress, giving a score so far of +2-0=1 for Kolisch. La (Nouvelle) Régence of Aug. 1860 (p.253) has the same result. Shakhmatniy Listok of Jan. 1861 (p.4) has +3-0=1 for Kolisch. The Manchester Weekly Express and Guardian of 18 May 1861 says that Barnes won 1 out of 13 games. The Era of 26 May 1861 and the New York Clipper of 22 Jun. 1861 give +12-1=1 for Kolisch. Perhaps the most consistent interpretation of these confusing reports is that the started in July 1860, when they played 3 games with a score +2-0=1 for Kolisch, and finished in May 1861, with a score of +10-1=0 for Kolisch, totalling +12-1=1 over the entire 14 games. I will list these two results separately, one in each year.
 
References
Books
   Di Felice, Chess Results, 1747-1900, page 31
   Feenstra Kuiper, 100 Jahre Schachzweikämpfe, page 16
   Golombek, Golombek's Encyclopedia, page 166
   Hooper and Whyld, Oxford Companion (1st ed.), page 170
Periodicals
   [CPC], vol. 3, June 1861, page 185
   [Era], vol. 23, 26 May 1861, page 14
   [ILN], vol. 37, 18 Aug. 1860, page 164
   [MWEG], 18 May 1861
   [NR], vol. 1, Aug. 1860, page 254
   [NYC], 22 June 1861
   [SL], vol. 3, Jan. 1861, page 4
Web
   Spinrad, Jeremy P.  [Collected results, 1836-1863]
   Steinitz, Wilhelm.  [Death of Baron Kolisch]

Match information updated: 14 Nov. 2015