| Results |
| |
| Crosstable scores |
| Name |
Edo |
Dev. |
Score |
/ |
Games |
| Crum, John |
2168 | (66) |
7 | / | 9 |
| Fraser, George |
2176 | (52) |
6.5 | / | 9 |
| Spens, Walter |
2077 | (43) |
6 | / | 9 |
| Forsyth, David |
2025 | (57) |
5 | / | 9 |
| Andrews, G. (1) |
2078 | (76) |
4.5 | / | 9 |
| Mills, Daniel |
2212 | (41) |
4.5 | / | 9 |
| Gilchrist, John |
2054 | (54) |
4 | / | 9 |
| McLeod, James |
1994 | (65) |
3 | / | 9 |
| Chambers, John |
1950 | (52) |
2.5 | / | 9 |
| Fyfe, Peter |
1976 | (53) |
2 | / | 9 |
|
| |
| |
Event table notes
|
| Event data |
| Name: 1st Scottish Championship |
| Place: Glasgow |
| Start date: 21 July 1884 |
| End date: 25 July 1884 |
| |
| Notes: |
| Gaige has 'Cilchrist' at this event, but the British Chess Magazine has 'Gilchrist', and Di Felice and McGowan have John Gilchrist. Di Felice has 'Andrews, Henry John Clinton' here, but this is very unlikely, as H.J.C. Andrews was primarily a problem composer, not a player, and was based in London, with no connection to Scotland, as far as I am aware. Gaige has only 'Andrews'. McGowan identifies him as 'G. Andrews', and Saunders says that 'G. Andrews' was a pseudonym for George Andrew Thomson, though on what basis is not clear. Andrew Hunter is listed in some sources as 'Andrews' at Glasgow 1875, which could be a typographical error or could mean that Hunter used 'Andrews' as a pseudonym. It is unlikely to be Hunter here, however, since the Chess Player's Chronicle says that Andrews would have preferred to play in the Minor Tournament, but agreed to play in the Major Tournament at the request of the committee, and Hunter was too strong for that. I will guess that this was indeed the G. Andrews who wom the Minor Tournament in 1888, and I will not identify him with George Andrew Thomson, without more convincing evidence. |
|
| |
| References |
| Books |
| Di Felice, Chess Results, 1747-1900, page 92 |
| Gaige, Chess Tournament Crosstables I, page 41 |
| Sergeant, Century of British Chess, page 192 |
| Periodicals |
| [BCM], vol. 4, no. 8, Aug. 1884, page 320 |
| [CPC], vol. 8, no. 213, 30 July 1884, page 53 |
| Web |
| McGowan, Alan. [First Congress of the Scottish Chess Association] |
| McGowan, Alan. [John Crum] |
| Saunders, John. [Tournament: 1st Scottish Chess Championship] |
| |
